FANDOM


This is the page where all of the voting for the next article to be featured in the Main Page's Relevant Works section. To place your vote, sign your username under either the pass or the decline section on this page. To leave a comment, place it under the comments section.


February 2009 Edit

The Haram Empire (Winner)Edit

Pass

  1. Flamefang - Considering that this article is my own. As well as being by far my longest and most illustrious of articles. I vote for this page to be February's relevant work!
  2. DJ 1337 Man I'm kind of neutral on this, but I support it nonetheless.
  3. Lars (Poet) (speak page) 20:59, 26 January 2009 (UTC)
  4. Mattkenn3 Talk

Decline

Comments

Thanks for the nominations! Flamefang 02:44, 26 January 2009 (UTC)Flamefang

The page is very nice. It provides much detail and there are very few grammatical errors. It also provides several internal links. On the down side, the infobox has no title and there aren't many images. I feel that, if this article is to become featured as a relevant work, it needs to have more images. Mattkenn3 Talk 23:29, 25 January 2009 (UTC)

KaileEdit

Pass

Decline

Comments

This article is not as nice as The Haram Empire article. It has a good introduction and provides several links to other pages. But, it has less content than the other articles and does have a few red links. If the article gains more content, with images to help add a visual aid to the content, and create articles for the red links; the article could be worthy of recognition. Mattkenn3 Talk 23:35, 25 January 2009 (UTC)

FubadubiaEdit

Pass

Decline

Comments

Although the mood of this article is less serious as the others, it still has a good amount of content and gives us a good understanding of the land and those that inhabit it. The article has several internal links and provides images to help its readers better understand the article. Mattkenn3 Talk 23:40, 25 January 2009 (UTC)

ClabraEdit

pass

decline

comments

This is more of a wiki project than an actual article. Perhaps we should move it to Constructed Mythology:Clabra. What do you guys think? Mattkenn3 Talk 01:06, 27 January 2009 (UTC)

Category:Clabra has only 2 atricles, but it is true that Clabra/Ideas contains what some other wikis would perhaps have placed in sepparate articles. I think that this could be done by using Category:Clabra and perhaps also subpages. Lars (Poet) (speak page) 16:03, 27 January 2009 (UTC)

The Acroturian EmpireEdit

pass

decline

comments

This article contains a good bit of content. There aren't that many grammatical errors. But, the article contains no internal links and doesn't have any images. Mattkenn3 Talk 01:08, 27 January 2009 (UTC)

March 2009Edit

KaileEdit

Pass

Decline

Comments

This article has a good introduction and provides several links to other pages. But, it has less content than the other articles and does have a few red links. If the article gains more content, with images to help add a visual aid to the content, and create articles for the red links; the article could be worthy of recognition. Mattkenn3 Talk 00:16, 2 February 2009 (UTC)

Fubadubia (Winner)Edit

Pass

  1. Leon - Very nice article, there are links and images, not too long but not too short. Has a good chance on the main page as the Relevant work.
  2. Mattkenn3 Talk- Actually, I think it's a really nice article. I'm going with Fubadubia.

Decline

Comments

Although the mood of this article is less serious as the others, it still has a good amount of content and gives us a good understanding of the land and those that inhabit it. The article has several internal links and provides images to help its readers better understand the article. Mattkenn3 Talk 00:18, 2 February 2009 (UTC)

AzuncazuncEdit

Pass

Decline

Comments

The Acroturian EmpireEdit

pass

decline

comments

This article contains a good bit of content. There aren't that many grammatical errors. But, the article contains no internal links and doesn't have any images. Mattkenn3 Talk 00:18, 2 February 2009 (UTC)

Races of TurasEdit

pass

decline

comments

This article has a good bit of information and gives detail on all of the races of Turas. It is well written and is worthy of recognition for this. But, the article provides no internal links. Also, it has no images. If these two problems were fixed, this article would definitely be ready for the relevant work section on the Main Page. Mattkenn3 Talk 00:24, 2 February 2009 (UTC)

PoholaEdit

pass

  1. Glaenia I'd say Pohola over the Races of Turas. Turas is more known about, but I am pausing work on that project... at least on the Wiki. I've devoted much more energy to De'tetoom recently, and Pohola was the first nation I fully fleshed out (save for history...) on De'tetoom.

decline

comments

The article has a good bit of content and provides detailed information about it's subject. But, it has no internal links and no images. If it were to gain these, it would look much better and would be an even better choice for our Relevant Work. Mattkenn3 Talk 00:46, 2 February 2009 (UTC)

I'd say Pohola over the Races of Turas. Turas is more known about, but I am pausing work on that project... at least on the Wiki. I've devoted much more energy to De'tetoom recently, and Pohola was the first nation I fully fleshed out (save for history...) on De'tetoom. Glaenia

NetherWorldEdit

pass

  1. Spritegage - Actually, since I created it, I think the article was thrilling as if YOU were a part of the realm- like you have something to do with it... Like you could help it. I think this concept and many others is grand in many ways.... I do not think I EVER worked so hard in such a short time.

decline

comments

NetherWorld is the series and branches of mini-articles all put into one big article, in which I am nominating... This article gives great imagery and the artistry in words is fluent. NetherWorld is rather different with its DIARY concept and THE BOOK OF RIN. The opening was very stunning.

First off, in your introduction paragraph you describe the map of the NetherWorld. The article would be better if, for example, instead of saying that the white represents the crystal feilds; describe the crystal feilds and then state that the crystal fields are represented by the white areas on the map. Do you understand? So, instead of describing the map to us, describe the land to us. If the map has a key, we will be able to decipher it easily. Also, the article has several grammatical errors, along with punctuation and formatting errors. If these few problems are fixed, along with lengthening the article, providing it with internal links, and adding images to give a visual aid to the information, this article could come out pretty nice. Mattkenn3 Talk 19:49, 23 February 2009 (UTC)

Malichan LanguagesEdit

pass

decline

comments

  • While I appreciate that someone nominated one of my articles, I find it odd that someone nominated one of my lesser articles. I will remain neutral on this one, because something else is more deserving of this title than my Languages page. DJ 1337 Man 05:46, 21 February 2009 (UTC)
  • Well, did you look at the nomination right below this one? Mattkenn3 Talk 20:58, 22 February 2009 (UTC)

MalichaEdit

pass

decline

comments

Pretty nice article, in my opinion. It could be lengthened. Although it is relatively short, it gives us a good understanding of the realm. It has several internal links. It also has a great map that helps us understand the lay of the land. In my opinion, this article is worthy of recognition. Mattkenn3 Talk 20:58, 22 February 2009 (UTC)

Bas'chiunEdit

pass

decline

comments

A Brief History of MalichaEdit

Pass

  1. As the nominator for this article, i also place my vote for it. My reasons are stated below.Flamefang 19:42, 21 February 2009 (UTC)Flamefang

Decline

Comments

  • I feel that this article is a worthy candidate for recognition because it seems a well written, thought out and organized page. Although this article is long by this Wiki's standards, it remains visually deficient. Despite having no images, this article is well written to the point where they aren't actually necessary, and so i wish this article and its creator luck in the upcoming "election".

Flamefang 05:56, 21 February 2009 (UTC)Flamefang

April 2009 Edit

Baltos (Winner)Edit

Pass

  1. As the nominator and creator, I'd have to place a vote for it. Details are below. Re4leonscottkennedy 14:53, 3 March 2009 (UTC)

Decline

Comments

Baltos is not too long, and not too short. It's an organized page with a fair number of branching articles and images. I think it's one of my best works yet and is a worthy candidate for the vote. Re4leonscottkennedy 14:53, 3 March 2009 (UTC)

Here we go again. I was hoping that this wouldn't happen again. Every time, the creator of an article nominates and votes for their own article. I understand that if you think your article is worthy of recognition, you should nominate it. But, what I don't like is when every editor nominates and votes for their own article. I think that the users in this community should read my policy proposal at Constructed Mythology talk:Community Portal. Read the proposal very carefully. It confuses some people. But, look it over. Mattkenn3 Talk 01:09, 1 April 2009 (UTC)

May 2009Edit

KaileEdit

Pass

  1. --Mattkenn3 Talk

Decline

Comments

This article has a good introduction and provides several links to other pages. But, it has less content than the other articles and does have a few red links. If the article gains more content, with images to help add a visual aid to the content, and create articles for the red links; the article could be worthy of recognition. Mattkenn3 Talk 01:56, 15 April 2009 (UTC)

Well do keep in mind that this article is meant to function as a general introduction to the world as a whole, and also as a sort of index from where you can easily navigate around the articles about Kaile itself. As a result its not meant to have much specific content.

VOTE FOR IT! ^.^

Flamefang 03:07, 15 April 2009 (UTC)Flamefang

Races of TurasEdit

pass

decline

comments

This article has a good bit of information and gives detail on all of the races of Turas. It is well written and is worthy of recognition for this. But, the article provides no internal links. Also, it has no images. If these two problems were fixed, this article would definitely be ready for the relevant work section on the Main Page. Mattkenn3 Talk 01:57, 15 April 2009 (UTC)

PoholaEdit

pass

decline

comments

The article has a good bit of content and provides detailed information about it's subject. But, it has no internal links and no images. If it were to gain these, it would look much better and would be an even better choice for our Relevant Work. Mattkenn3 Talk 00:46, 2 February 2009 (UTC)

October 2009Edit

The Haram EmpireEdit

I nominate my own article: The Haram Empire. I understand that this article has been nominated and featured before, however i consider it to be one of the most thorough articles on the wiki and feel that it would provide a nice example of what this wiki is trying to achieve. Other comments are welcome

Flamefang 02:19, October 4, 2009 (UTC)Flamefang

Pass

Decline

Comments

True. It has been used before. Once I figure out this whole infobox problem, we can add it. --Mattkenn3 Talk 19:19, October 4, 2009 (UTC)

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.